Blog

Atherton Measures Construction Deadlines From the First Permit, and the November 20 Rules Fit Less Work Into Each Month

Atherton's new construction rules take effect Friday, November 20. Three ordinances the Town Council adopted on October 21 apply 30 days after adoption: a rewritten Construction Management and Operations Plan, revised Construction Regulations and a new "Do Not Solicit" list. Most of the attention has gone to parking, delivery trucks and notice to neighbors. The rule that sets the cost of a slow project is older, and its numbers didn't change. The October 21 staff report says the construction time limit program moves into a new Chapter 15.41 "without changing its substantive requirements," and that the Council proposed no changes at that meeting.

The deadline stays the same while the new operating rules fit fewer working hours into each month of it. For anyone buying a teardown, buying a project already under way, or selling a home with a build in progress, the date the original permit was issued affects the price.

The clock starts at the first permit

Chapter 15.41 covers all construction done under a building permit. That includes new construction, additions, alterations, substantial remodels, repairs, demolitions and the related landscaping. The time limits come from a three-tier table, and each one counts from the original building permit's issuance:

Project size in the Chapter 15.41 table Time to complete
2,000 square feet or less 12 months
2,001 to 4,000 square feet 24 months
Greater than 4,001 square feet 36 months

The ordinance says time limits "will not be increased by issuance of subsequent building permits for the same project." A revision, a second permit or a design change doesn't restart the count. Completion is marked by the Town's final inspection and approval of the work, after all construction materials and debris have been cleared from the site.

The table has two drafting quirks. The column heading reads "Building Permit Valuation," but the tiers are written in square feet. The ranges also skip a project of exactly 4,001 square feet. On a project near either boundary, ask the Building Department which tier it falls in before you rely on it.

What a late finish costs

The penalty schedule increases the longer a project runs past its limit. The first 30 days carry no penalty. Days 31 through 60 cost $200 a day, up to $6,000. Days 61 through 120 cost $400 a day, up to $24,000. From day 121 the penalty is $1,000 a day with no stated cap.

The schedule also requires deposits. When a project reaches its limit without a final inspection or certificate of occupancy, the owner must give the Building Department $30,000 in cash, a certificate of deposit or a penalty bond. If the project is still unfinished on day 120, the owner must deposit another $220,000. Missing either deposit leads to a stop-work order. Penalties that exceed the deposits become a personal debt of the owner and may become a lien on the property.

For example, take a project that finishes six months late, or 180 days past its limit. The penalties alone come to $90,000:

  • $0 for days 1 through 30
  • $6,000 for days 31 through 60
  • $24,000 for days 61 through 120
  • $60,000 for days 121 through 180

By then the owner has also posted $250,000 in deposits, and the penalties are deducted from them. Once a project passes day 120, each additional week adds $7,000.

The Chapter 15.41 ordinance text has no routine extension. It offers two forms of relief. The first is an appeal, which can be filed only after construction is complete. It goes first to the Planning Commission, for delays beyond the control of the owner and the owner's representatives, and then to the City Council. The appellant must provide documentary evidence of diligent, timely project preparation and of the delays, either when filing or within two weeks. Without that evidence, penalties can't be modified or waived. The second runs through the Building Official. If the owner submits a documented explanation along with the first deposit and the Building Official accepts it, finishing within 30 days avoids forfeiture. If the work takes longer and the Building Official agrees, the penalty is waived and the deposit or bond is returned. Either way, keeping documents from the start of the project is what makes relief possible.

November 20 limits how much work fits into each month

The Construction Management and Operations Plan ordinance came out of a Builders Roundtable meeting with about 50 builders and residents. Under the new rules, contractors and homeowners on larger projects must sign a standard CMOP Agreement as a condition of the building permit. Final changes at the October 7 study session covered Heritage Tree protection zones, where portable toilets can sit relative to a neighbor's property line, and owner site visits outside normal construction hours.

None of these rules adds to the 12, 24 or 36 months. Several of them limit how much work a crew can do within those months:

  • A five-day workweek. Under the standard CMOP Agreement, construction, deliveries, pickups and servicing happen Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Other than qualifying emergency work, activity outside those hours needs an approved Exemption Permit. The required plan notes prohibit work or site access on Saturdays, Sundays and holidays, including hauling and heavy-equipment activity, unless an exemption or emergency applies.
  • Set start times. Workers can't arrive or wait at or near the site before 7:30 a.m. Delivery, pickup and service vehicles can't arrive, wait or stage before 8:00 a.m., and they must leave by 5:00 p.m.
  • One truck at a time. Only one delivery vehicle per project may occupy the public right-of-way. Other delivery vehicles have to stay outside Town limits until the one ahead of them is leaving. Trucks must use the route and access point in the approved plan, and commercial vehicles can't stage or queue on public streets.
  • Parking on site first. Construction vehicles park only where the approved plan allows. Narrow streets and some cul-de-sacs get little or no on-street parking. Projects of 2,000 square feet or less get no on-street parking unless they receive an exemption.
  • People and enforcement. Every job posts a responsible site contact and gives neighbors advance notice before disruptive work. Enforcement includes citations, fines and Stop Work Orders.

Planned after-hours work requires an exemption application at least 72 hours in advance and notice to properties within 300 feet. Approval is discretionary, and emergencies are handled separately. In practice, a crew that falls behind can't count on Saturdays to catch up.

The smallest projects are affected most. A project of 2,000 square feet or less has the shortest limit, 12 months, and loses on-street parking by default. Its staging, crew parking and materials all have to fit on the lot. On a tight lot, that can slow work early in the 12 months.

More rules are coming

The Council also introduced changes to the Town's construction and demolition recycling rules, and they were scheduled for adoption on November 18. Under the proposal, the 75% recycling requirement stays, only GreenWaste, the Town's franchise hauler, may supply debris boxes, and continuing violations can be cited. Starting January 1, 2027, the online Green Halo tracking system would replace the current deposit process. GreenWaste Recovery's exclusive debris-box franchise took effect January 1, 2026. The changes follow recommendations from R3 Consulting that the Refuse and Recycling Committee supported. A project that runs from 2026 into 2027 could fall under two debris tracking systems.

The Town's calendar also lists a first reading of a Heritage Tree ordinance for January 20. The new CMOP already includes Heritage Tree protection zones, so any project with mature trees on site has another rule change to watch early next year.

Questions to ask about a property with a project under way

Under the rules taking effect November 20, the time remaining on a permit carries real weight in a project's value. When an Atherton listing comes with active permits, or a sale is planned before a build is finished, these questions are worth putting to the Building Department, your builder and your attorney:

  1. What date was the original building permit issued, and which Chapter 15.41 tier applies to the project?
  2. How many months are left on the clock today, and does the builder's schedule fit within them on a weekday-only calendar?
  3. Have any deposits under Chapter 15.41 been posted, or have any penalties started to accrue?
  4. Does the project have an approved CMOP and a signed CMOP Agreement, and does the approved plan's on-site parking and staging match what the lot can actually hold?
  5. What record of delays and their causes has been kept so far, in case an appeal is ever needed?
  6. How does the purchase contract handle the time remaining on the clock, any posted deposits and any penalties accrued before closing?

Nothing in this post is legal, tax or financial advice. It is general information about Town rules, and anyone buying, selling or building should confirm how these rules apply to their property with the Town of Atherton Building Department and their own attorney.

Gretchen Swall helps Atherton buyers and sellers turn permit dates, deadlines and deposit exposure into clear pricing and negotiating terms. Schedule a confidential consultation to review a specific property before November 20 or soon after.

Work With Gretchen

A natural born problem solver, Gretchen is known for her resourcefulness in challenging situations. As an agent who is prepared for all situations and knowledgeable in her craft, she is a huge asset to her clients and is thorough in educating them every step of the way.
Contact